No businesses can rely on just one marketing mechanism. As a matter of fact ‘one’ is a pretty dangerous number in business:
one major supplier
one vital employee
one main customer
In the 'olden days', if your business used Yellow Pages as its only promotional mechanism, a ‘Not happy Jan!’ moment* was a severe blow. And could not be corrected for a year.
Today's newer equivalent is reliance on high rankings in Google – one algorithm update or a decision that you are breaching the rules (the ‘Google slap’) can remove you from the rankings entirely.
The same is true of Facebook – all pages and information on Facebook belong to Facebook and they’ve been known to shut pages down with no notice whatsoever and without giving a reason.
Evaluate additional marketing tactics
With everyone's focus on online and social media, other 'old fashioned' conventional marketing methods are being ignored. Direct mail for example.
Although direct mail is more expensive than online and email marketing, here are some of the reasons it’s worth considering including in your marketing mix:
not subject to same strict anti spam rules
you can just rent a targeted list and send to it without worrying about spam implications**
you can be more creative in print
designed correctly, your mailing piece has (potentially) a longer ‘life’ than email
can be read anywhere
can be used to target people who are not computer/internet focussed (more than you might imagine)
Getting different marketing tactics to work together
The most successful companies have taken all of this a step further and have cracked the code of getting online and offline campaigns to work together – with for example direct mail driving traffic to the website and the website asking for mailing addresses from online visitors.
Take a relatively recent example from Canada – a marketing campaign by Staples, one of the largest stationery and office products companies in North America.
Staples decided to test once and for all which was better – the conventional print marketing put out by their ‘offline’ team or the email marketing put out by their ‘online’ team.
So they divided up their database and did a test – one batch went via print only, one via email only, and a third batch got both an email and a print flyer.
Interestingly, the test didn’t answer the question, as the email only and print only campaigns saw a very similar response rate.
Here’s the kicker, though: the combined print/email campaign pulled six times the response rate of either of the other two individual campaigns.
A while back, when I set up a site for fans of Italian cars (www.italiancar.net), the original focus was on promoting it exclusively online, but I soon found that offline promotion worked really well to drive people to the site.
I got some smart looking fridge magnets made and would give them away instead of business cards, often leaving them under the windscreen wipers of Italian cars I spotted (or throwing them on the seats of the open top Ferraris etc when parked).
The magnets were a talking point and a simple and non-intrusive way of promoting the site. The site went on to hit 75,000 visitors a month based on a mix of off and online promotion.
*’Not happy, Jan!’ – catchcry of a business owner left out of the Yellow Pages by a forgetful employee (Jan) in the ad campaign (in Australia) for the company several years ago - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_happy,_Jan!
**we strongly recommend against using any list of email addresses you have not collected correctly yourself, even if you have bought the list from a reputable broker